Favorite Movie?

As soon as I read your comment about the missing characters for the sixth I went onto IMDB and you're right, they aren't there...how are they going to manage that? What is going to happen with the prophecy?!?!!?

I really don't know what they are going to do without Dobby, and at this point, if people have only seen the movies what are the chances of them remembering a relatively minor part that came about 6 years ago? And they usually try to make novel interpretations so that you didn't have to read the book...Maybe Kreacher will take Dobby's roll, and then Kreacher just wont die...

Well when it comes to discussing the hair styles I definitely liked PoA hair styles the best! Especially Ron's honestly, that was the only year I liked our leading Ginger's hair out of all of the movies.

But if we're talking the actual movies, I would have to say OotP! I loved his directing! He did it so well! When I was watching the movie the parts that he skipped from the book I hardly even noticed! While in all the other movies I noticed every single missing tid bit.

Like I'm still be-grudging Chris Columbus for cutting out Peeves' character! Since he didn't put him in the first two movies none of the directors could put him in any other one either! Which stinks because he had a pretty cool part in the fifth book I think. I'm not belittling Mr. Columbus' directing though aside from the lack of Peeves I thought he did good.

Alfonso... the directing for PoA (don't hate me please!) could've been better in my opinion. Maybe I had such high expectations for this one because it was my all time favorite book out of all 7 (it introduced the Marauders). I was thoroughly dissappointed in the movie... aside from the amazing hair.

I wasn't a huge fan of the 4th movie because it seemed sloppy, like Newell directed it I think... anyways, like Newell didn't really seem to careful about the little things. Then there was there hair... I got a little nauseous when I saw it...

Anyways, don't hate me for disliking 3 so much! I put my hopes up too high and I think that was my problem.

PoA, because of Sirius and the directing was phenominal.

GoF because of the Triwizard Tourney, The Quiddich cup, and Cedric!!!

probably OotP, it was a pretty good adaptation from the book and it made me cry, which is a good thing for me. I'll probably change my mind when HBP comes out though

ihave to say PoA. it's not my favorite plot, but the way it was filmed......wow. i just think it was filmed so much better than the others. well done, alfonso

I definitely agree about PoA's filming. That was incredible. I think Alfonso's version of the Hogwarts grounds was the best.

Although I really hate Remus's mustache. I would like to have a word with whoever decided to give him that.